| 角色 | 饰演者 | 角色介绍 |
| Brad Sexton | 蒂姆·艾伦
 | |
| Caroline Sexton | 柯尔斯蒂·艾利
 | |
| Samuel Yoder | 杰伊·桑德斯
 | |
| Phil Kleinman | 迈克尔·勒纳
 | |
| Bob Lachman | 韦恩·奈特
 | |
| Insp. Derek Lester | 拉里·米勒
 | |
| Frank Hall IRS | 小米盖尔-A·努耐兹
 | |
| Levinia Yoder | Megan Cavanagh | |
| Henner Lapp | John Pyper-Ferguson | |
| Rebecca Yoder | 凯莉·普雷斯顿
 | |
| Jerry | 伊桑·菲利普斯
 | |
| Dave | John Caponera | |
| Anna Yoder | Katie Moore | |
| Samuel Jr. | 博比·斯泰戈特
 | |
| Sammy Yoder | 迈克尔·安格拉诺
 | |
| Grandma Yoder | Rosemary Knower | |
| Grandpa Yoder | David Harscheid | |
| Baby Yoder | Hunter Stover | |
| Baby Yoder | Scout Stover | |
| Judge Joan Northcutt | June Claman | |
| Cynthia | 玛拉·马普勒斯
 | |
| Mary | Holly Rudkin | |
| Penny Brad's Secretary | Crystal Bock | |
| Hannah Yoder | Monica Deeter | |
| Jonathan Yoder | Richard Pelzman | |
| Sarah | Madeline Mager | |
| Elder Joseph | Terrence Currier | |
| Elder Thomas | Hal Handerson | |
| Bailiff | Michael Howell | |
| Emma Yoder | Johanna Cox | |
| Jacob Yoder | Stefan Aleksander | |
| Teller | Holly Atkinson | |
| Evelyn Phil's Secretary | Emily Chamberlain | |
| Malik the Cabbie | Anthony Azizi | |
| IRS Agent | David Maples | |
| George | Markus Flanagan | |
| Tourist Man | Wes Johnson | |
| Tom | Rick Foucheux | |
| Waitress | Drenda Spohnholtz | |
| Stacy | Marla Sucharetza | |
