| Mike Flaherty | 保罗·吉亚玛提
 | |
| Jackie Flaherty | 艾米·莱安
 | |
| Terry Delfino | 鲍比·坎纳瓦尔
 | |
| Stephen Vigman | 杰弗里·塔伯
 | |
| Leo Poplar | 波特·杨
 | |
| Cindy | 梅兰妮·林斯基
 | |
| Eleanor | 玛格·马丁戴尔
 | |
| Stemler (as David Thompson) | David Thompson | |
| Jimmy Reed | Mike Diliello | |
| Shelly | Nina Arianda | |
| Gina Flaherty | Marcia Haufrecht | |
| Judge Lee | Sharon Wilkins | |
| Abby | Clare Foley | |
| Stella | Penelope Kindred | |
| Stella | Sophia Kindred | |
| Stuart Thatcher | Tim Ransom | |
| Woman Jogging | Jacqueline Brogan | |
| Woman #2 Jogging | Marceline Hugot | |
| Regional Ref | Michael Goodwin | |
| Staff Member | Earl Baker Jr. | |
| Frank | Edmund Ikeda | |
| Steve Deluca / Principal | Joseph Tiboni | |
| Ref | Edwin Thompson | |
| Church Soloist | Pam Levine | |
| Sheffield Coach (as Darren C. Goldstein) | Darren Goldstein
 | |
| Referee | Michael D. Davey | |
| Betty | Ann M. Hayes | |
| Kenny Randall | Rudy Lanzillotta III | |
| Carol's Match #1 Opponent | Ryan Arnel | |
| Kyle's Match #1 Opponent | Kevin Antero | |
| Zack Lowenstein's Match #4 | Chris Sarro | |
| Stemler's Match #4 Masked Opponent | Dante Porrazzo | |
| Zachary Lowenstein (as Dariusz Uczkowski) | Dariusz M. Uczkowski | |
| Thomlinson | Chris Federlin | |
