| Kate | Heidi Ervin | |
| Jack | Steven J. Wilson | |
| Ben | Wynn Reichert | |
| Guild member | Ryan Smith | |
| Guild member (as Steven C. Knapp) | Steven Knapp | |
| Guild member | D. Brian Smith | |
| Guild member | Joe Southards | |
| Victim | David Ditmore | |
| Victim | Daniel Dones | |
| Victim | Mary Barkaszi | |
| Victim (as Gina Nikole) | Gina Barkaszi | |
| Victim | Tony Barkaszi | |
| Victim (as Dominic Jordan) | Dominic Barkaszi | |
| Victim | Kristen Chandler | |
| Victim | Brian Woollard | |
| Victim | Will Pettus | |
| Victim | Chad Riden | |
| Victim (as Justin Jansen) | Justin Janssen | |
| Victim | Todd Pewitt | |
| Victim | Billy Hardwick | |
| Victim (as Phil Cordell) | Philip Cordell | |
| Victim | Tom Delfino | |
| Victim | Paige Hager | |
